“That’s not REAL writing”


KAT VANCIL

THE STORYTELLER'S SAGA

QUEST 93

Well hello there, Reader!

A few weeks back I saw a post on Reddit where a guy asked:

“AITA for making fun of my girlfriend for writing Fanfiction and claiming it’s actual writing?”

He seemed to think he wasn’t (the asshole). Oh boy, did the community have news for him. 😬

Now this dude is far from the only one out there who thinks this way, but he couldn’t be more wrong. And I’ll prove it with 5 ways that writing fanfic not only makes you a better storyteller, it can even become a legit job.

5 Ways Fanfiction is “Real Writing”

1) Helps You Develop Your Skills

Maybe you just want to practice scene construction, or dialogue, or non-verbal characterization without doing all the heavy lifting of designing a story world or creating bespoke characters.

Maybe you need more practice writing women characters that don’t feel like talking furniture.

Then grabbing a prompt and writing a short fanfic can be hugely beneficial. Especially if you’re doing it as a daily or weekly story writing exercise.

Some film, game, and musical groups have even been known to host writing challenges as promotions and allow aspiring storytellers to use their IP.

2) Alternative Universe Bonus

Sometimes it’s fun to snatch up a few characters from a creative work (or even your own) and plop them down in a new setting or situation outside the original plot.

Fantasy or apocalyptic manga set in an ordinary high school. Holiday specials that are completely divorced from the plot. Reimagined fairytales with… Wait what?

You might not realize it at first, but reimagined stories are essentially AU fanfics of the originals.

Looking for a great example of AU in action? Then check out the Marvel/Disney+ animated series What If…?

3) Media Adaptation

I’m not talking about a simple one-for-one book-to-film adaptation like The Hunger Games. I’m talking about something like Howl’s Moving Castle. If you’ve read the book and watched Miyazaki’s film, you know they are in no way the same story.

Or Seven Samurai by legendary film director Akira Kurosawa vs the anime Samurai 7 by Gonzo. Or how ENNEAD by Mojito is totally not the Egyptian mythology you learned in middle school.

4) Ghostwriting & Writing FOR Media

Now when it comes to fanfiction, we have to acknowledge the elephant in the room. Plagiarism is baaad However, mimicking the style and voice of another person isn’t as easy as it seems. This is why there’s a whole job for it.

So if it happens to be in your toolset, a career in ghostwriting or working for a production company might be for you. This is because when it comes to writing for TV, the characters’ personalities can only vary within a small tolerance from episode to episode.

(Fresh out of college, I did the illustration equivalent of this as an in-house artist for a children’s product company. We had licenses with everyone from Disney to DC to Nickelodeon. My job was to color and/or touch up the art assets I received from the art department and make sure they still matched our very strict character spec sheets.)

5) Licensed Works

It can literally pay to write fanfic. I’m talking about licensed works. There’s the simple kind—novelizations of films you see cropping up in bookstores and Targets right before the movie releases.

Then there’s the often overlooked kinds of books that fill shelves in every department from picture books to New Adult. Side story spin-offs, storyverse extra adventures, backstory epics—you name it. And every one of them is fanfiction.

Back in 2017/18, I was contracted by Amazon Publishing through their Kindle Worlds imprint to write a licensed work. In my case, it was a standard-length young adult novel (65K words). I was paid an advance and earned monthly royalties from sales.

When Amazon shut down Kindle Worlds in July 2018, the rights to the work were returned to me. And after a lot of editing (I had to remove all the copyrighted IP after all), that out-of-print novel became Predestined.

The point is, Reader, don’t let someone tell you that your fanfic writing isn’t “real” writing. Or that you’re wasting your time. Because those skills you’ve developed writing side quest adventures for your favorite characters might just turn into a career.

Well until next time, Reader, this is your friendly neighborhood storytelling Kat wishing you a wonderfully creative week.

Your cohort in storytelling,

Kat Vancil

🐱

PS 👉 My favorite fanfiction example of all time is Bungo Stray Dogs written by Kafka Asagiri and illustrated by Sango Harukawa. Each character is named after an influential author throughout history, and their powers are based on said author’s books.

That’s like writing a fanfic about every author on your bookshelf while simultaneously giving them superpowers.

Also, fun fact: any works in the public domain are 100% fair game when it comes to fanfiction.

Did your friend, co-worker, or some rando you met at a con forward this email to you?

First off, they have good taste.

Secondly, you can join the Storyteller's Saga too and get edutaining emails delivered to your inbox weekly by clicking the golden button below.

Image for Hi! I'm a Fantasy Sci-Fi Author With a Character Growth Focus!

Hi! I'm a Fantasy Sci-Fi Author With a Character Growth Focus!

I'm F.J. Blooding, a once USA Today bestselling author. I write urban fantasy, science fiction, epic fantasy, and epic urban fantasy with a character growth focus. I'm happiest when I'm growing people, which sounds really strange, but that's who I am and what I do. The people around me who aren't actively hiding from life, use what I do and what I give them to create amazing lives for themselves. My stories have rich characters, as long as you can read the body language tags, who don't always make the right decisions. We don't make stupid decisions for the sake of plot twists, but they're still sometimes dumb with real consequences. My earlier works were still a bit fumbly as I attempted to figure out what kind of writer I am, but my newest works deliver, and I'm hugely excited about them. I write, primarily, in three universes: Whiskey-verse where most of our urban fantasy and my one epic urban fantasy stories reside. Dreamland where my epic urban fantasies live. And, finally, Black Systems where our science fictions stories spawn. Happy reading!


Not interested in learning to be a storyteller? Just want to get news on my upcoming stories and read some heart-pounding Boys Love fiction instead? Abandon this quest

Do you need/want to change your name or email? You can update it here

Don't want to hear from me like ever again? Just Unsubscribe

The Saga Quest

1179 West A Street, Suite 137, Hayward, CA 94541

I’m Kat! Professional Storyteller & Neurodivergent Creative

Here to help you vanquish those story construction obstacles, slay that imposter syndrome clawing at the back of your brain & stomp boredom flat with heart-pounding Boys Love fiction. Join the Saga and choose your inbox obsession, whether it’s helpful advice to get your writing unstuck or an episode of my weekly Boys Love Fantasy series to devour during your coffee break.

Read more from I’m Kat! Professional Storyteller & Neurodivergent Creative
‘Sometimes your story idea is too advanced for the skills you currently have. And that’s okay. It doesn’t mean you’re a bad writer. Or that you should give up.’ — Kat Vancil, “The most embarrassing thing ever!”, The Storytellers Saga

KAT VANCIL THE STORYTELLER'S SAGA QUEST 97 If you’ve ever been to the SF Bay Area, Reader, you know we have this thing called False Summer in March and April. The temp jumps up to the mid-80s, and we all have to break out the tank tops and fans for a few days. All of mine are generally from the Men's section of Target (or were). Mainly because they’re long and go up to my collar bone. And now that I think about it, they sorta remind me of the very first “big girl” swimsuit I ever had when I...

‘All of these situations parallel very human ones—feathers aside. Which is probably why these celestial maiden stories are so prevalent that nearly every culture on earth has one in its fairytales and lore.’ — Kat Vancil, “What do shapeshifting waterfowl

KAT VANCIL THE STORYTELLER'S SAGA QUEST 96 Beautiful and graceful-limbed dancers balancing on the point of a toe as they spin in feathered, moon-pale costumes. Timeless and tragically evocative music you’ve definitely heard in a commercial or two. A maiden transformed into a bird by a dastardly sorcerer. An enchantment that can only be broken by an oath sworn by one who has never loved before. I’m of course talking about Swan Lake, 🦢 my second favorite ballet. My first, of course, being The...

‘Hats off to Rebecca Yarros for her choice to make Violet Sorrengail a waif with Ehlers–Danlos syndrome. Because as someone with chronic illnesses I can in NO WAY relate to a character that’s the equivalent of an Olympic marathon runner, scaling mountains

KAT VANCIL THE STORYTELLER'S SAGA QUEST 95 Well hello there, Reader! After returning home from our nieces’ 5th birthday this past weekend, me and my husband were flipping through the streaming networks looking for a movie to watch. Crime Dramas... Chinese TV SciFi & Fantasy… Epic Worlds… Period Dramas… Strong Female Characters… What’s this…? Among the various shows and movies you’d expect to see was Damsel (2024). And if you haven’t seen it yet, it’s well worth the watch. Damsel’s plot is...