But what if I made it dark…


KAT VANCIL

THE STORYTELLER'S SAGA

QUEST 79

Well hello there, Reader!

While talking to a friend about her upcoming novel, we got into a discussion about Cozy Fantasy, Dark Fantasy, and if there existed such a thing as Dark Cozy Fantasy.

Well, one of my upcoming stories—Seventh Swan—is exactly that.

It’s a cozy slice-of-life where two young guys run a bakery in a fantasy kingdom’s capital. But also one of them spent a couple hundred years forcibly transformed into a swan 🦢 and might have been baked into a pie as a child by his false mother. 😬

But maybe I should back up a bit. Because you might be wondering what exactly is “Cozy Fantasy”?

Well, Cozy Fantasy is a sub-genre born from the Slice-of-life genre of fiction and animation made popular by anime in the 90s and live-action shows like Dawson’s Creek.

Basically, the Slice-of-life genre is a depiction of the mundane, everyday experiences of ordinary people. School drama, work stress, human relationships, and the common struggles people face.

Cozy Fantasy just took that the Slice-of-life genre and said “But what if there was magic?

Need some examples of Cozy fantasy to get a better idea of what I’m talking about? I’ve got you covered, Reader.

Kiki’s Delivery Service

First up is Miyazaki’s Kiki’s Delivery Service. Let’s just wholesale ignore the fact she’s 13 and you’ve basically got a New Adult story about a girl living on her own for first the time.

Kiki has to find an apartment, learn to cook her own food, and establish herself as a solo businesswoman. She also just happens to be a witch who can ride a broom, and has a talking black cat familiar named Gigi.

Star vs. the Forces of Evil

On first look this seems like a zany magical girl show. But you’d be wrong. Yes, Star Butterfly is a princess from a magical kingdom. And yes, she can do magic. But she’s terrible at it. So terrible her parents feel she can’t be trusted with the responsibility of her powers and send her to our magicless world.

The first season+ of the series is Star living as a foreign exchange student with Marco Diaz and his family. Thus she lives in a normal American household, attends a normal public high school, and dresses like a normal teenager. (I swear you can buy that outfit at Target or maybe Hot Topic and I 100% would have worn it.)

But the point is, the story isn’t her and Marco trying to save the world or fight a demon lord. It’s normal tween stuff with the complication of one of them having access to a magic wand.

So what’s Dark Fantasy then?

It’s not that shiny Lord of the Rings-style Fantasy where the main characters are paragons of goodness.

It’s darker, grittier, and the Legendary Character doesn’t necessarily have to be a good person, just an interesting one.

Dark Fantasies are the sort of stories where the main character can be a terrible person. They can frequent brothels. They can curse and drink and get absolutely covered in monster guts and it doesn’t feel out of character at all.

It’s sorta like the cousin of Noir or Cyber Punk in that way.

Examples of Dark Fantasy

The Witcher
Carnaval Row
Coraline
They Come ay Night

And now we get to the sub-genre that started this whole conversation—

Dark Cozy Fantasy

These 3 stories are every bit as cozy (slice-of-life) as the ones I mentioned at the beginning of this email they’re just—well—a bit darker.

Howl’s Moving Castle

When you really think about, Miyazaki’s Howl’s Moving Castle is about a found family of outcasts trying to maintain a functioning household and keep their home business afloat amidst a looming war. On top of that, the titular character Howl is a draft dodger in more than one country.

And then you throw in the magic. Several of the characters are wizards, several are cursed, one made a deal with a fire demon when he was a child, and their “castle” is a steampunk wonder that prowls the misty mountain wasteland.

Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End

The story of Frieren isn’t about Himmel’s party of heroes’ 10-year quest to kill the Demon King. It’s about what happens 70 years later when the elven mage Frieren embarks on a journey to reach the resting place of souls in order to reunite with her former comrade Himmel.

Along the way, she acquires two young companions. And through interactions with them, Frieren slowly learns what it is to be human—despite being an elf.

But what shifts the story into the realm of Dark Cozy Fantasy is—well—it’s sad. There’s a pervasive melancholy of not realizing what you have until it's gone on top of the harsh brutality of the setting as the story progresses.

Practical Magic

One of my top fav Halloween holiday movies, Practical Magic is definitely Dark cozy Fantasy. Don’t believe me? Here’s a simple breakdown.

Practical Magic is about a widowed single mom raising two little girls while running an apothecary in a small East Coast town. On top of that, she’s an orphan who’s moved her little family into her aunts’ big ol’ house.

Everything’s fallen into a sustainable norm until she has to rush to the aid of her sister and save her from domestic abuse. And then they commit accidental homicide and her “normal life” goes off the rails.

And then you throw in the magic. They’re all love-cursed witches. They try to resurrect the abusive ex-lover, but he comes back wrong. So they kill him again, and the sister gets possessed instead.

So I hope this helped clarify these 3 sub genres of Fantasy for you, Reader. And maybe you’ll even consider trying your hand at a Dark Cozy Fantasy in the future.

Well until next time, this is your friendly neighborhood storytelling Kat wishing you a wonderfully creative week.

Your cohort in storytelling,

Kat Vancil

🐱

PS 👉 This month I’m participating in a group promo with 30+ other authors so if you’re looking to fill your TBR shelf with a 🏳️‍🌈 book or 20, come check out the collection!

Did your friend, co-worker, or some rando you met at a con forward this email to you?

First off, they have good taste.

Secondly, you can join the Storyteller's Saga too and get edutaining emails delivered to your inbox every Wednesday by clicking the golden button below.

Image for Steven J Morris

Steven J Morris

SJMorris Writes

Hi! If you enjoy fantasy with snarky humor, I've got some books for you. My newsletter takes you along the creative journey, and keeps you informed of what's brewing.


Not interested in learning to be a storyteller and just want to read some heart-pounding Boys Love fiction instead? Abandon this quest

Do you need/want to change your name or email? You can update it here

Don't want to hear from me like ever again? Just Unsubscribe

The Saga Quest

1179 West A Street, Suite 137, Hayward, CA 94541

I’m Kat! Professional Storyteller & Neurodivergent Creative

Here to help you vanquish those story construction obstacles, slay that imposter syndrome clawing at the back of your brain & stomp boredom flat with heart-pounding Boys Love fiction. Join the Saga and choose your inbox obsession, whether it’s helpful advice to get your writing unstuck or an episode of my weekly Boys Love Fantasy series to devour during your coffee break.

Read more from I’m Kat! Professional Storyteller & Neurodivergent Creative
‘THE ULTIMATE TIME SAVERS - 3 FREE tools you can use right now as a storyteller’ — Kat Vancil, “A feast of FREE tools for you”, The Storytellers Saga

KAT VANCIL THE STORYTELLER'S SAGA QUEST 85 Well hello there, Reader, While everyone else has got Black Friday Deals for you and whatnot, I thought I’d share 3 (mostly FREE) tools I’m grateful for instead. Scrivener Since 2010, I’ve done all my story writing exclusively in this program designed by a UK company Literature & Latte. Hands down, it’s the best writing program I’ve worked with and I’ve never considered switching to anything else. I use it for everything. Story creation, daily prompt...

‘From an alien’s perspective, humans are just plain weird. We murder trees, slice them up, tattoo things on their skin, store them like trophies on shelves of their bones in houses made of their skeletons.’ — Kat Vancil, “But what if no one likes it?”, Th

KAT VANCIL THE STORYTELLER'S SAGA QUEST 84 But what if no one likes it? It’s a common fear among newbie storytellers,Reader. It’s ingrained right down to the bones. Like showing up to the first day of school and getting mocked for your hair or backpack or glasses. That fear of being singled out is at the very heart of what it is to be human. We want to blend into the herd, the pack, it’s how we stay safe. It’s how we keep from getting eaten. But…the point of art—of storytelling—IS to stand...

‘If you’re feeling overwhelmed or disillusioned, you’re NOT alone. It’s OKAY. Your feelings ARE valid. Whether it’s rage, or numbness, or the desire to eat your body weight in lavender honey ice cream.’ — Kat Vancil, “It’s perfectly okay to NOT be okay”,

KAT VANCIL THE STORYTELLER'S SAGA QUEST 83 It’s perfectly okay to NOT be okay right now, Reader. Because the outside world is A LOT at the moment. The implosion of NaNoWriMo. The banning and destruction of all we hold dear in this world. The dystopian fascist hellscape that America has become. It’s enough to make you want to crawl under a blanket and hibernate until 2028. Trust me, Reader, if you’re feeling overwhelmed or disillusioned, you’re not alone. It’s okay. Your feelings are valid....